(A little late, but here we go.)
So I read a lot of fic, and some of it is pretty awesome. My creteria for inclusion on this list is pretty simple. First, it has to be a fic I
found in 2011, not necessarily that it was published. Second, it's not enough to just be good or even great, because if I counted things that way this list would extend into the hundreds. Instead, a fic has to be
memorable to be included here, something I'll remember months after the fact.
In alphabetical order...
Fallout: Equestria -- (Fallout / My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic) --
Fallout... with ponies! Set in an alternate future, it follows the story of Littlepip, a rather underwhelming Stable-dwelling unicorn in a post-apocalyptic Equestria. Stuck in the monotony of one of the lowest ranking jobs in the Stable, her life changes when she leaves in search of Velvet Remedy, the Stable's singer idol. Outside, she must learn to survive in a blasted, poisoned land... and possibly, with the aid of friends made along the way, bring new light into the darkness of the Equestrian Wasteland.** The hell with alphabetical order,
this is my favorite fanfic of 2011. Its premise is undeniably cracky, yet the author delivers a thumping good story with excellent characterization, a clever fusing of both mythologies, extensive use of Chekhov's gun in a way that never feels cheap, and also deconstructs a lot of Fallout's gameplay in a thoughtful way. It's a difficult fic to sell -- I myself avoided it like the plague until it reached the mid-20s in chapters -- but
Fallout:Equestria is a captivating read that few fics I've ever read have managed to equal.
moves in mysterious ways -- (Twilight) --
Sometimes the prey evolves, or at least learns how to issue restraining orders.** Despite the above summary, it's not a hatedom fic, although the text is critical of some of the original novel's thinking. Instead it's an oddly heartwarming riff on the plot of the first Twilight novel, set eighty-ish years in the future and with the gender roles reversed. By the end of the fic, even anti-fans might finds themselves feeling sympathy for Bella Cullen.
Speech Acts -- (AtLA) --
What if, instead of martial arts, bending was based on sign language?** Some AUs are sprawling, elaborate epics like the above-listed
Fallout: Equestria, but at the opposite end of the spectrum you have a fic like this. There's not a spare ounce of fat on this lean fic as it tackles it's basic "What if?" question to its fullest.
Unsteady Ground -- (Axis Powers Hetalia / 1984) --
Oceania likes to tell people that he knows exactly what they’re afraid of.** I've got a few issues with the fundamental concept of Hetalia, but that doesn't prevent me from enjoying this standalone crossover. What happens to a bunch of anthropomorphized countries when they get absorbed into a totalitarian super-state that wants to erase any evidence of their existence? Nothing good. Yet despite this fic's darkness, there's still moments of hope.
Wreckage -- (NGE) --
Basically, it's an AU where Yui and Kyoko are still alive in 2015—** Wait! Wait! Come back! It's different from the million other fics with that same premise, I swear! For one thing, it shakes up Eva's rigid
Stations of the Canon by not having Shinji arrive until before the
5th Angel and by Asuka already living in Japan. Another major divergence is that Ritsuko, not Misato, becomes Shinji's guardian in Tokyo-3. In fact, Misato is pretty much a secondary character in this fic, the same way Ritsuko was in canon. Also, Yui and Kyoko? Not exactly Mother of the Year material in this story.
There are a few downsides. It's been six months since the last update. Also, the author drops the odd Star Trek joke now and then that jars with the overall Original Flavor tone of the fic. But those points aside, it's an Evangelion fic that refreshingly doesn't use it's AU nature to remake everything into a lighter and softer version of canon. Shinji starts off in-character and gradually develops into a better person; not a generic badass, but an ordinary teenager who makes an effort to reach out to people despite his fears.